VCAT Volume 11 No 2
1. Amendment C243 – emerging approaches at VCAT
Practitioners will be aware that Amendment VC243 gazetted on 22 September 2023 introduced significant changes to the Victoria Planning Provisions (VPPs) residential zones, including the codification of key residential development standards.
The codified standards generally relate to setbacks, wall heights on boundaries, building heights, daylight access, and access to private open space, and apply to all single dwelling and multi-unit development up to four storeys. Codification means that where an application meets the numerical standard in the relevant clauses, the objective associated with such standard is deemed to also have been met (i.e deemed to comply).
As readers of VPRs will note, we have addressed the uncertainty surrounding the question of whether a ResCode standard is deemed to meet the objective in a number of editorials (see VCAT Vol 1 No 1, VCAT Vol 2 No 13 VCAT Vol 3 No 3 and VCAT Vol 8 No 2). Amendment VC243 purportedly seeks to address some of this uncertainty.
Does VC243 finally put this matter to rest?
In D’Andrea v Boroondara CC [2023] VCAT 1148, which involved an application for the construction of 15 apartments in a three storey building above a basement car park, the Tribunal stated:
…. the codifying of certain ResCode standards is intended to provide, “certainty and clarity… about acceptable siting and design requirements for residential development.” In other words, it removes the discretion associated with a qualitative assessment informed by the relevant objective and decision guidelines, coupled with the context of a review site and the merits of a design response. [23]
In effect, the Tribunal indicated that it will be important that practitioners carefully consider all of the residential provisions as the application of some standards may impact on compliance with other standards, notwithstanding some provisions may have “deemed to comply.”
The Tribunal further stated:
Neighbourhood character and amenity related policies are still relevant where Standard B17 is achieved, but only insofar as they relate to the aspects of a built form that are still before the discretion of a decision maker, including the length of walls, articulation in the built form, and the use and arrangement of colors [sic] and materials. [28]
In Costa v Banyule CC [2023] VCAT 1273, which was a proposal for two dwellings, the Tribunal disagreed with D’Andrea in relation to limitations of the codification on built form matters. It stated:
Many of the standards that are now codified relate to amenity matters associated with a building form. However, it has long been recognised through clause 55 and its predecessors that standard built form controls across Victoria do not recognise specific features of a site or its surrounds including the character of the neighbourhood. In other words that one design solution (as is provided for in a codified design) may not necessarily be an acceptable design outcome on every site in every neighbourhood in every municipality. If that were the case, the Victoria Planning Provisions would have been modified to remove consideration of the neighbourhood character or to codify the consideration of neighbourhood character in clause 55.
The D’Andrea decision considers that it would be illogical and impossible to have no discretion over neighbourhood character outcomes and then to go ahead and apply that discretion and carry out an assessment. I do not share this opinion. Planning decision-making can be challenging, and this situation is evidence of this. There are multiple objectives throughout clause 55 that require consideration of neighbourhood character. Accepting some clause 55 objectives are met because the relevant standard is met does not negate the need to consider the remaining clause 55 objectives and exercise the general discretion that applies through the zone provisions. [31-32]
Accordingly, the Tribunal considered that, whilst codified standards such as B17 and B18 were met in the matter before it, it was still required to consider and determine whether the neighbourhood character objectives (and other non-codified objectives) are met.
VC243 no doubts seeks to simplify the assessment of the VPP residential provisions with the deemed to comply approach on certain built form matters. To this extent, it is clear that compliance with a standard now meets the objective. However, in Costa, the Tribunal held that built form matters extend to qualitative issues such as neighbourhood character, meaning that, whilst a proposal that meets all the standards also meets the relevant objective, that does not mean a proposal is automatically deemed to be acceptable. All relevant matters under the integrated approach to decision-making must be considered.
It will also be interesting to see how the Tribunal deals with future deemed-to-comply provisions and makes any commentary as to whether compliance with a standard has any implications on achieving an acceptable outcome, noting that Amendment VC243 does not appear to be underpinned by any built form analysis or typologies.
See also:
- Guide to Planning Appeals: ResCode
2. Concerns with flood impacts scuttles two developments
Two recent cases highlight concerns whether development is appropriate in flood prone land and whether flood risk management plans are adequate to deal with flood emergencies.
In the first case, Tivoli House SY Pty Ltd v Stonnington CC [2023] VCAT 798, the Tribunal considered a proposal for a 7–8 storey building for office use. Council was opposed to the proposal on a number of planning, urban design and flooding grounds.
The land is in the Land Subject to Inundation Overlay (LSIO). Melbourne Water is a determining referral authority to the proposal. It was opposed to the proposal on the basis it is contrary to the LSIO objectives and flooding policy at Clause 13.01 of the planning scheme as it considers the proposal will intensify the impacts of flood risk through the increase in floor area proposed, and cause an unreasonable flooding hazard to life, property and community infrastructure.
A Flood Risk Management Plan (FRMP) was prepared by the Applicant and a flood risk management engineer was called to give expert evidence at the Hearing. The evidence was that the flood risk to the property included:
- Existing building floors that are well below the designated flood level;
- Access and egress paths for the property are the same as for the proposed development and do not therefore meet the safety criteria found in the DELWP Guidelines; and
- There are no formal processes in place to manage people movements or relocation from the area in the event of a flood.
Proposed mitigation measures included:
- Raising floor levels to 600mm above the designated flood level;
- Provision of a passive self-closing flood barrier at the entrance to the car park;
- Installation of another passive self-closing flood barrier in the corridor between the car park and main entry foyer;
- Other engineering measures as detailed in Section 4.1 that are aimed at keeping flood water away from people and assets as far as is practical; and
- Use of a FRMP for the site that has appropriate regard for the effective management of risk to life and safety from both Prahran Main Drain and Yarra River flooding.
The Applicant argued that the proposed scale and intensity of the development is the kind expressly contemplated by the existing Activity Centre Zone Schedule 1 (ACZ1) controls and those controls have been developed cognisant of the potential flood risk of the site. It was submitted that:
- The potential for flash flooding attributable to the Prahran Main Drain has been well understood since before the introduction of the new format planning schemes.
- The strategic planning for Forest Hill and the development of the ACZ1 control was undertaken in the context of the LSIO applying to a significant portion of the ACZ1 area.
- As a consequence, the intensification of development in the Chapel Street Activity Centre has occurred in response to potential flood risk.
However, after detailed consideration of the submissions and evidence, the Tribunal concluded that:
We are not satisfied that the proposed development is consistent with the LSIO objective to minimise the potential flood risk to life, health and safety. Nor are we satisfied that the proposed development is consistent with the floodplain management strategy set out in clause 13.03-1S, to avoid intensifying the impact of flooding through inappropriately located development.
The proposed development is a substantial increase in floor area that in turn leads to a substantial increase in employment population in this area of complex flooding, presenting a high risk. While there are objectives within the ACZ1 provisions to intensify development in the Chapel Street Activity Centre, we are not satisfied that, for this site, these ACZ1 objectives outweigh the impacts of flooding risk.
Further, we are not satisfied that the proposed flood risk management measures manage the risk appropriately for this development, where the depth and flow of floodwater, affecting access and egress to the property, is hazardous. The review site is subject to high flood risk, well above the DELWP Guidelines safety criteria, for both the Yarra River flood and the Prahran Main Drain flash flood.
Our findings about the failure to meet the LSIO objectives particularly relate to the reliance on shelter in place as a flood risk management strategy when the best practice information in the FRM Handbook is that a shelter in place strategy should not be used to justify a new development which increases density in the floodplain.
In conclusion, we support Melbourne Water in taking a risk-informed approach to land use planning for this proposal. This development should not be approved due to the flood risk associated with this location. [197-201]
In the second case, AVC Operations Pty Ltd v Maribyrnong CC (Red Dot) [2023] VCAT 925, Council had refused an extension to the beer garden and associated buildings and works that would have accommodated an additional 800 patrons (reduced to 656 patrons following amendments to the plan) at the well-known Anglers Tavern along the banks of the Maribyrnong River. This site was significantly impacted by the October 2022 major flood event.
Originally, the application for permit included reference to the number of patrons but this was subsequently amended because existing use rights did not trigger a permit for an increase of patrons. However, the Tribunal considered a reasonable inference that the Applicant intended to seek a licence variation under the Liquor Licensing Reform Act 1998 to increase maximum patron numbers if it was to allow the application in this proceeding.
The proposed buildings and works require permission under the LSIO that applies to the subject land. Melbourne Water, as the relevant floodplain management authority, objected to the grant of an amended permit stating that the proposed expansion of the existing premises is not consistent with the approach of minimising potential flood risks to life, health and safety associated with development.
There was no dispute amongst the parties about the flood risk to the property. However, the Applicant relied on the FRMP to argue that, by relocating the patrons, it was possible to mitigate the flood risk to people to an acceptable level, if not eliminate it. However, the Tribunal observed that the FRMP uses the word ‘relocate’. It preferred the word ‘evacuate’ as it considered it more accurately describes the temporary, urgent movement of people away from the immediate or anticipated threat of flooding.
In refusing to grant a permit, the Tribunal stated:
In this case there is an LSIO and policy in place which supports avoidance and minimisation of flood risk in this location. Notably, there is no competing policy in the planning scheme that encourages intensification of development in this location. AVC submitted that the Tavern’s existing use rights are or amount to a competing policy. We do not agree. Even if an existing use could amount to a competing policy, it is of little weight in these circumstances.
We are not satisfied that the proposed development is consistent with the LSIO objective to minimise the potential flood risk to life, health and safety. Nor are we satisfied that the proposed development is consistent with the floodplain management strategy in the planning scheme, to avoid intensifying the impact of flooding through inappropriately located development.
Further, we are not satisfied that this development achieves the direction for floodplain management in Victoria as set out by the VFMS of “avoiding or minimising future risks” through the use of planning controls to manage the potential growth in risk and “not making things worse.”
Given that the liquor regulator would not be taking flood risk into account in deciding a possible future licence variation application to increase maximum patron numbers, it is now (when the beer garden extension is being considered under the planning scheme) and only now when the increased population at risk during a flood is appropriately considered.
The proposed extension to the existing hotel, is an increase in floor area that in turn leads to a substantial increase in population at risk in this area of high flood hazard.
In our opinion, the proposal fails to comply with Objective 1 and fails to substantially comply with Objective 2 of the DELWP Guidelines, and comprises an unacceptable outcome with respect to flood safety and flood damage. [194-199]
The two cases above demonstrate that that the LSIO objective to minimise the potential flood risk to life, health and safety requires more than evacuating people in a flood emergency.
See also:
- Guide to Planning Appeals: Flood risk
3. Change to evidence – integrity of process questioned
It may be recalled that in Clifftop at Hepburn Pty Ltd v Hepburn SC [2023] VCAT 201 (editorial comment VCAT Vol 10 No 7), which involved a proposal for a caravan and camping park, the Tribunal held third party submissions could not be made on bushfire risk on the basis the site is not in the Bushfire Management Overlay.
Another key issue in the proposal was treatment of wastewater. An objector called an expert witness on hydrogeology. In the giving of evidence, the witness indicated he had ‘tweaked’ some information regarding wastewater volumes but that it didn’t change his conclusions. However, the evidence contained a new Land Application Area (LAA) that departed markedly in estimated field size from what had, up until that time, been understood to be the LAA that the witness had assessed was required.
The Applicant’s representative objected to the provision of this new information and sought an opportunity to obtain instructions. The Applicant’s concern was that this new information was provided so late in the course of the Hearing and without any notice having been given to the Applicant, such that the Applicant has not had the opportunity to consider the new LAA and its possible impact on the proposed site layout and design.
In its Interim Order, Clifftop at Hepburn Pty Ltd v Hepburn SC [2023] VCAT 224, the Tribunal ultimately ruled the expert evidence report of the witness admissible in the proceeding. However, during the course of the determination the Tribunal addressed a number of fundamental concerns that had been raised by the Applicant.
The Applicant requested for any and all correspondence in relation to the expert evidence that had occurred between the objector’s representative and witness and the witness and any other party.
The Applicant submitted that a document tabled by the objector’s representative demonstrated that the expert report was essentially written by the representative and not by the witness. Further, the Applicant submitted that the representative not disclosing the way in which this report had been prepared, and the extent of the representative’s involvement in the preparation of the report, amounted to ‘outrageous’ conduct by the representative.
The Tribunal stated:
In the Tribunal’s experience, what is now before us is an usual and uncommon situation; mercifully so, given that it calls into question the honesty and integrity of professionals in the exercise of their professional duties. The unusual nature of this situation is endorsed by comments made during the hearing days by professional advocates, many of whom have considerable experience appearing in this Tribunal.
The manner in which we conducted the hearing days that were given over to dealing with this issue, and the extent to which we have, in this decision, discussed the evidence that was given by Mr Williams, should be an indication of the seriousness with which we view these allegations and the importance of thoroughly assessing the allegations before us.
Further, the orders that we made prior to Mr Williams giving evidence were in aid of ensuring, as best we could, the integrity of the process by which Mr Williams would be giving evidence, so as not to invite any inferences of collusion between Mr Haydon and Mr Williams, or between Mr Williams and any other party.
It is not unusual for questions to be raised as to how an expert witness has been instructed, their level of involvement with a project before the preparation of an expert report (and, therefore, their impartiality and independence regarding a proposal) or what documents had comprised their brief.
Depending on the extent to which any answers to those questions tell against the impartiality of the witness, the issue then becomes the weight that will be given to that expert evidence by the Tribunal. That is, the expert evidence will be allowed to be called and relied upon by the party calling it and it will be a matter for the Tribunal as to how much weight it gives the expert opinion of that witness, depending on what has been said in response to those questions.
What is unusual about this case is that an assertion has been made that the way in which Mr Williams’ expert evidence report came to be prepared was so tainted, and the content and conclusions reached were so obviously directed by the party calling the evidence, so as to mean that the expert opinion of Mr Williams is of no probative value and is unworthy of being admitted into evidence at all. This is a strong accusation and the reason why Mr Williams was called to provide evidence as to these matters.
What is also unusual about this case are the associated allegations regarding Mr Haydon’s improper involvement in the preparation of Mr Williams’ expert evidence, along with the claimed breach of the notice requirements in VCAT Practice Note PNVCAT2 as regards Mr Williams’ change of opinion on a material matter. This has led to the CFA flagging that costs might be sought against Mr Haydon personally pursuant to section 109(4) of the VCAT Act, which is a power that is exercisable by the Tribunal but which is rarely, and cautiously, used. [145-151]
The Tribunal was satisfied that the witness demonstrated a clear understanding of his duties and responsibilities in preparing and giving evidence, including that he be impartial in giving his evidence and that the evidence ‘is what it is, who it favours is who it favours’. It considered that it will be a matter for questioning during his expert evidence testimony as to whether the witness can adequately explain his expert opinion, and this ultimately will go to the weight that the Tribunal gives to the witness’s evidence.
In relation to the addendum document, which included the changed LAA, whilst it appeared that this one-page addendum document was not provided to the Tribunal when it was provided to the objector’s representative, even if the document was filed at that time, and therefore met the requirements of PNVCAT2, this would only be approximately six days before it was ultimately brought to the attention of the Tribunal and the parties. In the context of the history of this application and the impact that the new LAA may have on the proposal, if the new LAA was correct, the delay of six days did not result in greater prejudice to the Applicant than if it was filed when provided to the objector’s representative.
Your editors note that the importance of complying with rules of evidence and the VCAT Practice Note PNVCAT2 cannot be emphasised enough. As noted by the Tribunal, the conduct in the proceeding might be thought to undermine the public’s confidence in the process.
See also:
- Guide to Planning Appeals: Evidence > Admissibility of evidence
4. Major Hazard Facilities and risk
There have been a number of cases involving applications for use and development in proximity to a Major Hazard Facility (MHF). The most recent case we commented on was Bujar Pty Ltd v Hobsons Bay CC [2023] VCAT 635 (editorial comment VCAT Vol 10 No 11), where the Tribunal refused an amendment to a permit to include the use and development of the land for a childcare centre and restricted recreation facility (gymnasium and yoga studio) on land located approximately 400 metres north-west of the Viva Newport Major Hazard Facility.
In Achieve Building Design Pty Ltd v Hobsons Bay CC [2023] VCAT 853, the Tribunal considered an application for two side by side dwellings within 720 metres to a MHF. WorkSafe noted that the application is within the Outer Safety Area (OSA) of the MHF and will increase the population of the OSA and set a precedent for future development. WorkSafe advised against issuing the permit. Council refused the application because of the proximity of the MHF.
The Applicant called expert evidence from a risk and hazard expert. His view was that WorkSafe exaggerated the level of risk to surrounding areas due to:
- Overly conservative measurement points (from the site boundary not the risk source); and
- The use of a risk criterion lower than is usual in other jurisdictions, resulting in an expanded identified risk area.
Further, he noted there are several physical characteristics in the area (including the separation distance to the site) that in his view mitigate risk, including, in summary:
- Ignition sources between the site and the MHF including the rail line and warehouses. Igniting an escaped flammable vapour cloud close to source is safer than letting it move further offsite to sensitive areas; and
- The barrier effect for any cloud of the buildings (warehouses) between the site and MHF and the rows of trees along the interface between housing and the warehouse area.
In setting aside the refusal, the Tribunal considered that if a permit for the dual occupancy is granted, it is a minor increase in population compared to the existing single dwelling. Further, in terms of risk assessment, it is considered that this is not an increase in likelihood from the MHF, rather it is an increase in consequence; that is, there are a small additional number of people in the OSA who may be affected by an incident. (Tribunal emphasis)
In summary, it considered the following factors in concluding the risk was acceptable:
- The distance of over 800 metres from the risk sources on the MHF to the site;
- The high potential for interim ignition of any escaped flammable vapour clouds.
- The low likelihood of favourable climatic conditions for vapour cloud spread at a high enough concentration for ignition.
- The barriers between the MHF and site.
The Tribunal also considered that approving this application is not a threat to the MHF: there is already a very large residential community within the Inner Safety Area (ISA) and OSA as defined by WorkSafe. Whether this application is approved or not the MHF operator must take this sensitive use environment into account in its operational planning and management.
It is worth noting that WorkSafe buffer areas are not part of the planning scheme. However, a planning authority has an opportunity to apply the Buffer Area Overlay. This Overlay was introduced into the Victoria Planning Provisions via Amendment VC175 in May 2020.
See also:
- Guide to Planning Appeals: Risk
5. Does an outdoor fireplace and chimney comprise ‘Domestic services normal to a dwelling’?
The increased popularity of outdoor living and external installations such as pizza ovens or smokers have the potential to cause adverse impacts such as smoke.
In Brumley v Stonnington CC [2023] VCAT 897, an objector challenged an approval given for alterations and additions to the existing dwelling. However, his sole concern in the submission to the Tribunal was the amenity impact of a proposed outdoor fireplace and chimney on the review site.
On behalf of the objector, it was submitted that while some outdoor fireplaces and chimneys might be considered normal to a dwelling, the design of this proposal is such in terms of its height, location and bulk that it is not a normal design for a chimney.
However, the Tribunal was not persuaded by these submissions for the following reasons.
- The definition of ‘Domestic services normal to a dwelling’ intends to only include services that are of a normal design; rather, the use of the word ‘normal’ in this definition refers to services that normally accompany a dwelling, which a chimney often and regularly does;
- The design of this chimney is not so unusual – while it might be more bulky than a narrow metal flue, the broader brick design is not unusual for a chimney associated with a dwelling. Outdoor chimneys, including those associated with pizza ovens, are becoming a more commonplace occurrence in the dwellings found across Melbourne’s suburbs; and
- As the entire land is to be used as a dwelling, the proposed outdoor fireplace and chimney is to service the dwelling, in this case being the outdoor components of the dwelling.
The Tribunal referred to Karunajeewa v Melbourne CC [2016] VCAT 417, which was determined by a legal member. In that decision, it was stated:
[13] The term “Domestic services normal to a dwelling” is defined in clause 72 of the Scheme as meaning:
A domestic appliance or apparatus that is normal to and services a dwelling. It includes disabled access ramps and handrails, an air conditioner, cooling or heating system, a hot water service, security systems and cameras, shade sails, a barbeque, downpipes and flues, a skylight, security screens, and the like.
…
[16] I determined that, having regard to the buildings and works sought to be undertaken, along with the operation of the planning controls in the Scheme, that the ambit of my discretion in terms of the current proceeding was as follows:
…
[d] Given the operation of clause 62.02-2 of the Scheme in exempting “domestic services normal to a dwelling” unless a permit is specifically required under the Scheme, the installation of the outdoor inbuilt fireplace along with the flue and cowl does not require planning permission under DDO35. I accept that given the inclusive nature of the definition of the term in clause 72, and the matters listed, that the outdoor inbuilt fireplace properly falls within this term, and thereby, the exclusion. It was put to me by the Respondents that, despite its specific inclusion in the definition of the term, the flue was not a domestic service normal to a dwelling because the fireplace (and flue) did not form part of the main house itself. I do not agree with this submission on the basis that the concept of “dwelling” in the Scheme is broadly defined to include buildings beyond just the main house and the whole of the land is being used for the purposes of a dwelling.
See also:
- Guide to Planning Appeals: Buildings and works > Exemption from permit
6. Clause 65 decision guidelines and scope of discretion
Submissions on the relevance of certain policies under various permit triggers continue to be made to the Tribunal, with reference to Brunswick Investment Project Pty Ltd v Moreland CC [2021] VCAT 1191 and other like decisions dealing with the National Trust principle and scope of discretion.
In Whiting v Warrnambool CC [2023] VCAT 887, application was made for a function centre. The application had been refused by Council.
The Applicant submitted that the ambit of the Tribunal’s discretion in this matter is limited to matters relevant to the purposes of the Farming Zone (FZ) and of Clause 52.24 Bicycle facilities, and policy directly relevant to the respective purposes of those two controls.
Reference was made to various reasonings in Brunswick Investment to support propositions about the limit of discretion being confined to the use, as it was originally applied for, but not in relation to matters under car parking provisions (Clause 52.06) or liquor licensing provisions (Clause 52.27) of the planning scheme.
In short, the Tribunal noted that the germane of the reasons in Brunswick Investment to be applied was that when considering the permission being sought, the relevant policy to be considered is defined by the permission (or permissions) being sought.
However, the Tribunal considered that, and as observed in Brunswick Investment, reference is also to be made to the statutory framework for decision that includes Clause 65.01 matters ‘as appropriate’ to the permissions being sought and the matters under sections 60(1), 60(1A), 62(2) and 84B of the Planning and Environment Act 1987 (P&E Act). The latter includes the following objectives of the (P&E Act):
(a) to provide for the fair, orderly, economic and sustainable use …. of land;
…..
(c) to secure a pleasant, efficient and safe working, living and recreational environment for all Victorians and visitors to Victoria;
The Applicant submitted that when having regard to the reasoning in Brunswick Investment, that the requirements and related policy outcomes of the Environmental Significance Overlay Schedule 2 (ESO2) were not relevant because there was no permit trigger under this application. If there were no permit trigger, and in following the reasons of Brunswick Investment, this would be true.
However, earlier in the determination the Tribunal identified that the proposal should have included an application for works, hence relevant policies under the Farming Zone (FZ) are now relevant. Accordingly, this does not mean environmental impacts from the use of the land are not a consideration in this proceeding nor the impact of the proposed use on adjoining land is limited to agricultural matters sought to be protected by the FZ.
Having regard to the decision guidelines and the purposes of the FZ, the Tribunal concluded that the environmental and amenity grounds raised by the Council’s grounds and those of the respondents were relevant to the exercise of the Tribunal’s discretion in this application. It considered this view was further supported by having regard to the objectives of the P&E Act when applied to the circumstances of this proceeding, notably those that require a decision maker to consider whether the proposal will interfere with a pleasant living environment for the nearby residents of rural dwellings, albeit in the context of those dwellings being in a FZ.
As noted in Brunswick Investment that in exercising a discretion for the ‘purposes for which it is conferred’, the purpose:
..will be identified from the words of the control itself, including the decision guidelines and from its context.
The decision maker can look at the other aspects of the planning scheme to ascertain the context in which the discretion has been provided and the possible basis of the discretionary provision.
Only those aspects of the Scheme relevant to this context will assist in the ascertainment of the purpose. The requirement for a permit does not open up the broad range of policy considerations or other matters which are not directed to the purpose for which the discretion is being exercised.
See also:
- Guide to Planning Appeals: National Trust principles > Relevance of specific clauses and decision guidelines in the planning scheme with control trigger
7. Is a new CHMP required if there is a different high impact activity?
Section 52(3) of the Aboriginal Heritage Act 2006 provides that the decision maker must not grant a statutory authorisation for the activity if the activity would be inconsistent with the approved Cultural Heritage Management Plan (‘CHMP’).
In Wegg Pty Ltd v Melton CC (Red Dot) [2023] VCAT 957, the Applicant applied to construct a gas pipeline about 3.5 km long. The pipeline was to replace an existing gas pipeline that lay beneath land intended mainly for residential lots. The new pipeline would be constructed closer to the escarpment on the western side of the subject land adjoining the reservoir within proposed public open space adjoining the escarpment under the Precinct Structure Plan (PSP).
There were three approved CHMPs: in 2009, 2012 and 2014. Given section 52(3) above, the Tribunal was required to consider consistency in relation to each of the three CHMPs.
It ultimately found the proposed pipeline was not inconsistent with either the 2009 CHMP or the 2014 CHMP, but was inconsistent with the 2012 CHMP.
The Tribunal provided detailed grounds why it considered the proposed high activity gas pipeline to be consistent with both the 2009 and 2014 CHMPs. In relation to the 2012 CHMP, however, it found that:
- The activity does not expressly include earthworks for the proposed pipeline, as it does in the 2009 CHMP;
- There is no references to ‘services’ within the public open space that is the area in which the proposed pipeline would be located, as there is in the 2009 CHMP;
- A complex assessment was carried out in preparing the 2012 CHMP. However, it is not as focused on the public open space area as was the case for the 2009 CHMP. For example, there are no shovel probe transects running parallel and near the alignment of the proposed pipeline;
- The ‘recommendations’ of the 2012 CHMP are more equivocal about harm from activities in the public open space area adjoining the reservoir. It states:
… there will be some scope for minimising harm in the proposed open space corridor on the western portion of the activity area adjacent to [the reservoir] with exception of an area required for a retarding basin. This will result in minimal disturbance in this area, which may also have the effect of protecting some of the cultural heritage deposits that are present.
- The inclusion in the activity description of ‘activities permissible in the UGZ zone’ suggests that the activity includes any activity for which permission may be granted in the UGZ. This includes the utility installation the subject of this proceeding.
The Tribunal red dotted the decision on the basis that the Tribunal held that the difference in characterisation as a high impact activity was not relevant to the determination of inconsistency under section 52(3). The characterisation is relevant for determining whether a CHMP is required. What is relevant under section 52(3) is the difference, if any, in the nature and scope of the activity.
See also:
- Guide to Planning Appeals: Cultural Heritage Management Plan