PPV Volume 11 No 1

1. Advisory Committee supports multi storey building above preferred heights at Fishermans Bend

The Fishermans Bend Standing Advisory Committee (SAC) has recommended approval of  a site specific amendment applying to 240246 Normanby Road, South Melbourne (See Fishermans Bend Standing Advisory Committee Report – Tranche 5 Report pursuant to Section 151 of the P&E Act.

The draft Amendment involves amending the Port Phillip Planning Scheme to facilitate the development of subject land by:

  • applying the Specific Controls Overlay to the subject land (SCO3)
  • amending the Schedule to Clause 45.12 (Specific Controls Overlay) to reference a new Incorporated Document
  • amending the Schedule to Clause 72.04 (Documents Incorporated in this Planning Scheme) to refer to the new Incorporated Document.

The development plans provide for:

  • a 25 storey (83.3 metres, and 87.8 metres to the top of roof plant) storey building comprising a six storey podium level, street setbacks of the upper levels of tower element of five metres and rear setbacks of five metres
  • 135 serviced apartments at levels 1-5, 115 apartments (of one to four bedrooms on levels (6-24) including seven affordable dwellings (five by one bedroom and two two-bedroom apartments equating to six per cent of total dwellings)
  • 569 square metres of ground floor retail floorspace in four tenancies (which with the serviced apartments/residential hotel provides for 4,400 square metres of non-dwelling floor space)
  • ground floor lobby and separate lobbies for residential and serviced apartments accessed off Normanby Road
  • basement level carparking including five share parking bays, 61 car parking spaces (in stacker bay arrangement and five electric vehicle charging bays), two motor bike spaces and storage arrangements for 153 bicycles
  • communal indoor and outdoor amenities
  • two crossovers.

There was an earlier proposal for a 33 and 30 storey development that was subject to feedback from the Department of Environment, Land, Water & Planning (DELWP), Port Phillip Council and the Fishermans Bend Taskforce.

The key issues addressed by the SAC that may be of interest to practitioners include:

  • The SAC’s terms of reference
  • Building height
  • Affordable housing mix

Terms of Reference

Both DELWP and the Taskforce submitted that the SAC’s Terms of Reference (specifically Clause 17b and 19c) curtailed the Committee’s ability to set aside the mandatory setback provisions of DDO30 provisions.

However, the SAC considered these ‘scope’ components of the Terms of Reference should not be read so narrowly and must be considered in the context of the SAC’s purpose set out in Clause 5 to advise the Minister on unresolved issues “to achieve appropriate land use and development outcomes” and after considering all the matters identified in Clause 19 and expressly excluding those set out in Clause 20 on which it is unable to consider submissions or evidence.

Further, the SAC considered that Clause 17 of the Terms of Reference must be read in a general way otherwise there seems little point in referring non-compliant proposals to the SAC which do not meet mandatory provisions and will not be countenanced. Ultimately it found it was incumbent on the SAC to provide its advice to the Minister in the context of Clauses 5, 19, 40 and 41 of the Terms of Reference.

Building height

DELWP, the Taskforce and Council all opposed the proposed height on the basis that it exceeds the preferred maximum building height of 20 storeys and because it will not achieve a ‘mid-rise scale’ (7 to 15 storeys).

It was contended by these submitters that the current controls and preferred heights should be applied and that exceedance of the preferred maximum height should only be allowed with good reason. It was submitted that the Proponent’s reliance on existing approvals where the preferred height was exceeded did not constitute a sufficiently good reason and that the SAC was directed to consider the cumulative impact of approvals by the Terms of Reference.

The Proponent submitted that the proposed height would add interest to the skyline and complement the emerging physical context and was critical of DELWP and the Taskforce, arguing that the agencies had given inadequate weight to the emerging physical context and have applied “blinkers of the DDO30 setback controls without proper regard to the physical context of the site and surrounds”.

The Proponent also submitted that the proposed height would “represent a superior urban design outcome”; that the proposal does not underdevelop the land; that there was potential for a higher building (that would continue to comply with the overshadowing requirements), but based on existing approvals, could add interest to the skyline.

The Proponent relied on the urban design advice that whether at 20 storeys or 25 storeys, a building on the site would be of the same built form character as the surrounding recent built and approved buildings and would “fit comfortably in this emerging pocket of similarly scaled and taller buildings.”

The SAC considered that the proposed height is acceptable, both within the context of approved and constructed developments, and within the planning framework for the Montague North precinct. It considered that the expectation is that developments of ‘16 storeys and taller’ will be achieved, and there is a preference for there to be a predominance of mid-rise ‘7 storeys to 15 storeys’, but that this must be read in the context of a fulsome review of the entire control:

  • the preferred height limit of 20 storeys for the M1 precinct
  • a design objective to the Schedule “to ensure, in Montague North, a mix of mid and high-rise scales with hybrid and podium-tower typologies”
  • the ‘preferred precinct character’ for Area M1 in Table 1 is “mid to high rise developments”

It stated:

If approved at 25 storeys, the proposal would sit within an immediate context (if the approved developments are constructed) with building heights that range between 15 storeys and 24 storeys and more broadly with heights that range between 38 storeys and 46 storeys. Within the context of approvals that have come before the Standing Advisory Committee, with the exception of the approval of the 38 storey building on the ‘gateway site’, the approvals have been considerably lower than ‘legacy’ permits and are aligned with the mid to high rise building definitions. The outcome, will in the Committee’s view, allow developments that respond appropriately to particular site opportunities and will respond appropriately to the preferred character for the precinct.

Affordable housing mix

The proposal provides seven social housing apartments (mix of one and two bedroom formats) that will be gifted to a registered housing provider. This achieves the six per cent minimum provision but excludes any three-bedroom dwellings in the mix.

Council’s initial submission was that provision of three-bedroom dwellings was required to meet with dwelling mix sought by Clause 22.15-4.3.

DELWP submitted that the registered housing agency or provider to whom the dwellings would be transferred should determine the appropriate mix based on their understanding of housing needs in the locality. It proposed a change to the Incorporated Document that allowed for a mix of one, two and three-bedroom dwellings “unless otherwise required by a registered housing agency or other housing provider”.

The Proponent considered there was no demonstrated need or benefit to include three-bedroom dwellings in the Affordable housing mix. It considered that the Affordable housing provision was consistent with the requirement. However, it agreed that the amended Incorporated Document provided sufficient flexibility to consider the final mix.

The SAC considered that was no compelling reason to depart from the requirements of Clause 52.15-4.3 and exclude the potential inclusion of at least one three-bedroom dwellings in the Affordable housing mix. It agreed however, that the final mix should be determined by the likely need, which is best determined by the registered housing provider.

See also:

  • Guide to Planning Panels: Procedural issues > Role of Panel/Advisory Committee, Activity centres > Built form and height controls > Housing > Affordable housing

2. Victorian Murray Floodplain Restoration Project EES 

In what appears to be a first for this type of proposal, a standing advisory committee was appointed to consider an Environmental Effects Statement (EES) and planning scheme amendment on the Victorian Murray Floodplain Restoration Project (Murray Floodplain Restoration Project EES Central (EES) [2023] PPV 17).

The project consists of nine discrete projects which aim to return a more natural inundation regime to land adjacent to the Murray River in Victoria to achieve specific ecological objectives. There are two project areas, the Belsar-Yungera Floodplain Restoration Project and Hattah Lakes North Floodplain Restoration Project.

The Minister for Planning determined an EES was required for the EES Central projects. The purpose of the EES is to provide a sufficiently detailed description of both projects, articulate their benefits and assess their potential effects on the environment. A planning scheme amendment was required for both the Swan Hill and Mildura planning schemes.

The two projects are the first package to be considered by the Victorian Murray Floodplain Restoration Project (VMFRP) Standing Inquiry and Advisory Committee.

The Committee’s Terms of Reference required it to review and consider any known views of the Registered Aboriginal Parties/Traditional Owner groups, or to seek their views if they are not already known.

The Committee noted that the project is in an area where Traditional Owners and Aboriginal parties and organisations have not been formally recognised under relevant legislation, either as a Registered Aboriginal Party or through a Recognition Settlement Agreement. The Committee extended an invitation to Traditional Owners to participate in the Hearing process, with the assistance of the Proponent. One Traditional Owner group participated in the Hearing, and the Proponent provided the Committee with correspondence from four other Traditional Owner groups during the Hearing. Otherwise the Committee had to rely on submissions of the Proponent on issues relating Aboriginal cultural heritage.

The Committee was satisfied that Traditional Owners have had opportunities to be involved in the development of the Project and the preparation of the EES, Cultural Heritage Management Plans and associated processes.

The Committee held that ongoing engagement is critical to achieving the VMFRP objective to facilitate Traditional Owner aspirations for restoration of the floodplain. The Environmental Management Framework appropriately includes a number of requirements for Traditional Owner consultation across various management, operating, monitoring, evaluation and reporting plans. It further requires the Project Control Group (Operation) to include an Independent Advisor in relation to Traditional Owner engagement and project management.

The Committee identified matters that were beyond the Terms of Reference scope. These matters included:

  • it was not open to the Committee to review or assess the merits of the policies under which the Project was developed
  • the Committee was confined to assessing the exhibited Project and possible modifications, not project alternatives.

Overall, the Committee found:

Overall there are no impacts that preclude the Project being approved or the EES Scoping Requirements evaluation objectives being achieved, subject to the Committee’s recommendations.

The expected benefits of the Project are significant, however they will take some time to realise due to ecological timeframes and a range of factors outside of the control of the Proponent and project partners, such as weather conditions and climate change. The Project is likely to result in net community benefit, however achieving this and specific project benefits will rely on successful mitigation of risks through implementation of the Committee’s recommendations in relation to the Environmental Management Framework and effective adaptive management. 

The Project is likely to result in an overall improvement to biodiversity values of the Belsar-Yungera and Hattah Lakes North floodplains, based on benefits to:

    • floodplain hydrology in the Maximum Inundation Areas
    • aquatic ecosystems and biota
    • terrestrial fauna. 

In broad terms, the Project is expected to deliver benefits to floodplain vegetation, including:

    • increased availability of water for water-dependent vegetation
    • reversal of territorialisation.

The EES, however, did not unequivocally demonstrate benefits for floodplain vegetation communities. Further analysis is required relating to floodplain hydraulics and implications for floodplain vegetation, to satisfactorily demonstrate and provide greater certainty that expected benefits will be achieved. 

The Committee recommends:

    • further analysis of hydraulic effects of the Project and implications for floodplain vegetation
    • outcomes of this further analysis be used to inform necessary detailed design or operational changes.

The alternative arrangement proposed to compensate for the removal, destruction or lopping of native vegetation and associated impact on biodiversity is generally acceptable, subject to the recommended further analysis and update to the assessment of overall improvement to biodiversity. The further work should be completed before seeking agreement from the Secretary of the Department of Energy, Environment and Climate Action for the removal of native vegetation, and any further requirements should be incorporated into the Environmental Management Framework.

As the further work is proposed to refine and address some uncertainties in the EES, to ensure the operation of the Project is ‘fine-tuned’ and impacts are avoided, mitigated and managed acceptably, it is proposed through Environmental Delivery Standards in the Environmental Management Framework (rather than requiring it to be done before the Minister for Planning’s assessment of the EES).

Other benefits are expected for:

    • soil, by increasing vegetation cover and stabilising soil and landforms
    • Aboriginal cultural heritage, by increasing vegetation cover, enhancing tree lifespans and reducing erosion
    • land use, by providing opportunities for environmental land practices, recreation, agriculture, improved visual amenity and access
    • agriculture, by replenishing ground and surface water and upgrading tracks
    • bushfire, by reducing the likelihood of fire ignition, reducing the rate and extent of bushfires, and improving bushfire resilience of vegetation
    • landscape character, by improving vegetation health and growth and improving quality of views
    • community and business, by enhancing the natural environment, delivering employment and associated economic benefits tourism and recreational benefits
    • traffic and transport, by improving tracks and access
    • air quality, by reducing dust emissions.

In relation to Matters of National Environmental Significance, the Committee finds:

    • impacts can be acceptably managed through recommended mitigation measures
    • the Project will not have significant residual impacts.

See also:

  • Guide to Planning Panels: Environmental Effects Statements

3. Amendment to Woolsthorpe Wind Farm permit

The Woolsthorpe Wind Farm in south-west Victoria was originally approved over 15 years ago. The approved wind farm comprised 20 wind turbines with a maximum overall blade tip height of 135 metres, tower height of 90 metres and blade length of 50 metres. Works have not commenced and a number of extensions to the permit have been granted.

Following a planning panel process in 2017 (Woolsthorpe Wind Farm Permit Amendment (PCI) [2017] PPV 32), the permit was amended under Section 97J of the Planning and Environment Act 1987, allowing for a maximum turbine height of 168 metres with a minimum 35 metres ground clearance, provision of a new site entrance, introduction of a secondary consent mechanism, requirement for noise to be compliant with the 2010 version of the New Zealand noise standard, and other minor changes.

In Woolsthorpe Wind Farm Permit (2006/0220/B) Amendment (PCI) [2023] PPV 26, the Applicant applied to amend the permit to reduce the number of turbines from 20 to 13, increase the turbine height from 168 metres to 230 metres, increase minimum ground clearance from 35 metres to 55 metres and associated changes including turbine siting and native vegetation removal.

The Project will maintain an overall power output capacity of 73 Megawatts, generating approximately 290 to 310 Gigawatt hours of electricity each year.

The Panel considered the proposeal raised the following key issues:

  • landscape and visual amenity
  • flora and fauna, in particular the Southern Bent-wing Bat (SBWB)
  • noise

In addition to the above issues, Moyne Shire Council raised concerns relating to permits that were granted, amended and extended multiple times. It referenced concerns documented by the Australian Energy Infrastructure Commissioner in its annual reports including (among others) projects being constructed based on outdated standards and requirements, very long periods of uncertainty for communities and other projects being planned and delivered in the intervening period with potentially unforeseen cumulative impacts. Notwithstanding these concerns, it submitted:

… Council acknowledges that the scope of the Panel’s inquiry is appropriateness of the Amendment Application. It is not open to the Panel to reconsider the appropriateness of this site for a wind farm. The Permit has been granted and the Proponent is entitled to act on it.

However, Council considered the Project represented a clear departure from the permission granted in the current planning permit. It submitted the potential impacts of increasing the height of a wind turbine is reflected in Clause 52.32 (Wind energy facility) which includes exemptions relating to amending a permit if the proposal does not seek to increase the maximum height of a turbine. Accordingly, Council submitted that the Panel’s scope of inquiry should be wide-reaching.

In response, the Panel stated:

A proposal to amend a wind farm planning permit is required to meet the relevant application requirements and is subject to the notice requirements of the PE Act. The application is required to be assessed against relevant planning policy of the day and a range of other considerations detailed in the Wind Energy Guidelines. The relevant Planning Policy Framework for the Project is established in the Planning Scheme.

It is in this context the Panel is tasked with assessing whether changes to the existing permit will deliver an acceptable outcome. The Panel accepts that the previous permit approval has determined the site is suitable for use of a wind farm. It is outside the scope of the Panel’s inquiry to reinterrogate the merits of a use for which a permit has been granted.

The Applicant is right to ‘be alive’ to the length of the planning permit process for this wind farm. The Panel notes the Applicant’s intention to progress the Project in a timely manner, given the extensive time since original approval. In the context of this approval’s history it is prudent for the Project to be delivered in a reasonable timeframe.

While the Panel is sensitive to the prolonged uncertainty for the community with the planning permit being modified and extended several times since originally being issued in 2008, this is not a basis for the Panel to approach assessment of the proposal as a new project.

The Panel does not accept Council’s suggestion that the Panel’s scope of inquiry should be more ‘wide-reaching’ on the basis the permit application is not subject to exemptions in Clause 52.32 (Wind energy facility). The Panel has been appointed to consider issues raised in submissions and to assess whether the changes to the proposal are acceptable and make recommendations to the Minister accordingly.

The Panel’s findings on the key issues are as follows:

Landscape and visual amenity

Consistent with the Wind Energy Guidelines, the Panel accepts the Project will be visible and will have a degree of impact on the landscape. Broadly the Panel accepts that the reduction in number of turbines from 20 to 13 will reduce the overall visibility of the wind farm. The increase in turbine height, however, has the potential to increase visual impact. The magnitude of visual effect varies depending on the viewing location and sight lines and context, such as surrounding landscaping and topography. As acknowledged in the VIA reports, the visibility of turbines and visual impacts for some locations will be greater than for others. Design of the wind farm and siting of individual turbines is important to achieving an acceptable outcome.

Flora and fauna, in particular the Southern Bent-wing Bat (SBWB)

The Panel concludes that:

    • The SBWB population is declining rapidly and needs to be afforded the maximum protection possible within the constraints of the proposed layout of the turbines.
    • SBWB behaviour is complex and based on the surveys at Hawkesdale and other sightings, the SBWB is likely to use the Project site.
    • Although the capacity to significantly relocate turbines away from SBWB habitat is constrained there is potential for turbines WT03, WT05, WT07, WT08, WT012 and WT013 to be micro-sited to achieve further small gains in protecting habitat.
    • The increased turbine height will reduce the possibility of most of the potential SBWB turbine collisions.
    • The development of a draft curtailment plan for the SBWB should form part of the BAM Plan.

Noise

The Panel considers that the assessment of background noise and predicted noise for operation of Woolsthorpe and Hawkesdale wind farms is comprehensive and has been confirmed by an independent auditor.

The Panel accepts the evidence of Mr Evans that cumulative noise impacts have been adequately assessed and noise limits can be complied with.

As the pre-construction noise assessment was based on a potential candidate wind turbine, a further pre-construction noise assessment should be prepared when the final turbine model is selected. This is adequately addressed in the permit conditions.

The Panel is satisfied the Project permit requirements and ongoing management and regulation as required by the EP Act and associated regulations and guidance will require any impacts to be mitigated to ensure noise limits are met. It is appropriate to delete the permit conditions relating to post-construction noise and noise complaints that are now redundant as a result of the changes to the regulatory environment.

The Applicant’s proposed planning permit included a modified version of the note suggested by the EPA, for example it did not include the website links. The Panel accepts the Applicant’s suggested drafting in the planning permit note. 

The Panel concludes that noise impacts of the Project are acceptable, subject to the Applicant’s final day planning permit changes.

The Panel’s draft permit condition requires the development to be started within three years of the date of the permit and to completed within six  years of the date of the permit (subject to any extensions being granted by the Minister).

Hopefully for surrounding landowners some level of certainty is provided with the commencement of the project. One of the challenges for the proponent that caused delay was that it was unable to procure turbines with specifications that comply with the current permit.

See also:

  • Guide to Planning Panels: Wind Farms > Landscape and visual impacts, Flora and fauna impacts, Noise

4. Flood controls should only apply to flood affected land only

Barwon and Moorabool Rivers have faced significant riverine floods over the past 150 years, with the most significant flood event occurring in 2011.

In Greater Geelong C339ggee Part 2 (PSA) [2023] PPV 42, it was proposed to revise flood overlays in the Lower Barwon River, Lower Moorabool River and Corio Bay coast. The Amendment revises the mapping extent of the Floodway Overlay (FO) and the Land Subject to Inundation Overlay (LSIO) and amends the schedules of the overlays by including floodway objectives, statement of risk, permit requirements, application requirements and decision guidelines.

One matter of note raised in the Panel report was whether a part of a property that is flood free should be included in the LSIO because that part of the land would be surrounded by flood waters in a 1 per cent flood event.

Council’s expert considered that that while it is not common for land that is not directly impacted by flooding to be included in a flood overlay, there are instances where this can be justified particularly when access to a site that is not flood prone is subject to significant flood hazard.

In finding that the Overlay should not apply to that part of the land not affected by flooding, the Panel stated:

The Panel understands Council’s, the CMA’s and Mr Bishop’s concern that any proposal on the flood-free portion of the land considers access arrangements across the portion that floods. The Panel does not consider, however, that this consideration requires the application of the LSIO to the flood-free portion.

Any permit application assessment on the subject land will discover that the FO applies to part of the land including through a VicPlan ‘planning report’ VicPlan.

The Panel considers that application of risk-based overlays should as far as possible cover the actual risk, noting that some minor reductions are appropriate to avoid unnecessary impost on land where only a small portion of a site is affected. The inclusion of a large area above the 1 per cent flood event in the LSIO only serves to confuse the role and application of the overlay.

The Panel notes that the Farming Zone which applies to the land contains the following provision:

A permit is required to construct or carry out any of the following: …

    • A building which is within any of the following setbacks: …
    • – 100 metres from a waterway, wetlands or designated flood plain or, the distance specified in the schedule to this zone. Any distance specified must be less than 100 metres.

No setback is specified in the schedule and so the 100 metres setback applies. All the land in the LSIO area is withing 100 metres of the FO and so it seems to the Panel that a permit is required for all buildings.

Overall, the Panel was satisfied that the Amendment was strategically justified and it was appropriate to apply the FO and LSIO subject to some amendments.

See also:

  • Guide to Planning Panels: Environmental policies – Inundation